October 26, 2026

Providence, Ambition, and Failure: Paul Lay Lectures on the Western Design

The Hamilton School welcomed historian Paul Lay for a lecture on Thomas Gage and the Western Design.

Gage was one of the more unusual figures of the seventeenth century: a Dominican friar from a recusant English family who spent years in Spanish Central America, converted to Protestantism, and later became an enthusiastic supporter of Oliver Cromwell. His book The English-American (1648) gave English readers their first substantial eyewitness account of the Spanish New World. More fatefully, Gage helped inspire the Western Design, Cromwell’s 1655 attempt to seize Hispaniola. The expedition collapsed in failure, forcing the English to settle instead for Jamaica.

Lay traced how Gage’s providential worldview, shared by Cromwell himself, collided with the practical limits of early modern warfare and logistics. The disaster left the Protectorate shaken and contributed to the authoritarian experiment known as the Rule of the Major-Generals.

The talk offered a vivid window onto the religious passions, imperial ambitions, and unexpected personal trajectories that shaped England’s early Atlantic empire.

Support the Hamilton School

Support